The International Criminal Court Has Dismissed SNAP’s Last Gasp


SNAP’s 2011 petition charged the Holy See with “crimes against humanity,” but the International Criminal Court unmasked SNAP’s true agenda – and rejected it.

Curses! Foiled again! I had made a decision to post more about my own paranormal quest during July – such as the cosmic implications of missing socks that I tackled last week. That resolve lasted only one week, however, before being foiled by a headline printed from The Media Report that just made its way to me via snail mail this week.

The headline was “The Hague Tosses SNAP’s Nutty Lawsuit Against the Vatican, SNAP’s Latest P.R. Stunt Exposed.” The Hague is the seat of government of the Netherlands, and the base of the International Court of Justice. It took almost two years, but the International Criminal Court has rejected a 2011 attempt to prosecute the Pope and the Vatican with a charge of “crimes against humanity.” The petition was brought by SNAP – the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. SNAP was aided and abetted in the petition by the radically left-leaning Center for Constitutional Rights based in New York.

In rejecting the petition last month, the International Criminal Court ruled that SNAP’s claims do not “appear to fall within the jurisdiction of the court” which accepts only cases reflecting “the most serious crimes of concern to the international community as a whole, namely genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes.” In other words, as The Media Report’s David F. Pierre pointed out, the ICC is not a place to air shameless publicity stunts.

And “shameless publicity stunt” was always the sole point of this petition. It was never a serious endeavor, and this outcome, though slow in coming, was always predictable. I predicted it in an October 2011 post on These Stone Walls entitled “SNAP’s Last Gasp! The Pope’s ‘Crimes Against Humanity.’ ”

The entire project was staged by SNAP and the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) just to generate headlines, and the mainstream media took the bait. News of the petition appeared in almost every major newspaper in the United States. In news interviews, CCR attorney Pam Spees described the SNAP petition:

“Crimes against tens of thousands of victims, most of them children, are being covered up by officials at the highest levels of the Vatican.”

The tone and content of the rhetoric was eerily similar – verbatim, even – to another propaganda campaign against Catholic priests that I wrote of in “Catholic Scandal and the Third Reich: The Rise and Fall of a Moral Panic.” Few of the same newspapers that trumpeted the SNAP petition against the Vatican ever bothered to cover the ICC’s summary dismissal of the case. We had to rely on the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights to issue a press release, and on The Media Report to publish this story. For me, the most shameful aspect of this SNAP publicity stunt was that I became an unwitting and unwilling part of it.

At about the same time SNAP filed its crimes against humanity petition with The Hague, The Media Report published a synopsis of new evidence and new issues in my appeal. It was entitled “Alarming New Evidence May Exonerate Imprisoned Priest.” Ignoring that new evidence – and maybe even in response to it – SNAP included some of the more lurid claims in the case against me in its petition to defame Pope Emeritus, Benedict XVI.

Some astute media writers picked up on this. Shortly after I wrote of this “crimes against humanity” charge in “SNAP’s Last Gasp” in 2011, I received a letter from JoAnn Wypijewski, a highly regarded writer on justice, law, and politics at The Nation and Harpers for over twenty years. She is clearly considered by many to be a writer on the social and political left – even the radical left – making her analysis of SNAP and this petition significant. Ms. Wypijewski wrote that she had been reading my new appeal brief at the National Center for Reason and Justice, and added:

“I am simultaneously reading CCR’s brief on behalf of SNAP. In truth, it is SNAP’s brief, flecked with all that organization’s typical arguments and phraseology. The brief mentions you, and claims that you videotaped having sex with your victims. It is typical of SNAP that every accusation is truth; the word, ‘alleged’ never appears with respect to claims made against priests. It is a disgrace.”

Of course, no one in SNAP or the CCR has ever seen such videotapes because they have never existed. “A disgrace” pretty much sums up this failed petition, but it also sums up the mainstream news media’s readiness to be continually duped by SNAP. The Media Report quoted Laurie Goodstein at The New York Times:

“It’s unlikely that the [International Criminal Court] will take this up, but they won’t be able to dismiss it easily. They may have to open up a preliminary investigation.”

That’s ridiculous, of course. The ICC dismissed the petition without much in the way of consideration because SNAP was clearly using it is a publicity stunt. Laurie Goodstein, like many in the media, was duped. The “investigation” she called for should have been carried out by the news media itself before it accepted being spoon-fed such unjust and uncorroborated claims from SNAP – claims that always seem to have the same goal in mind: to generate unquestioned settlements and keep the American Catholic ATM open and the cash flowing. The media’s all-too-ready stance to pursue anything anti-Catholic was analyzed in a recent post of mine entitled, “Strike the Shepherd: Behind the Campaign to Smear the Pope.”

Now that SNAP’s case against the Vatican is dismissed, I want to ask TSW readers to be vigilant about exactly what took place here. It all happened once before in an organized and highly motivated propaganda campaign – in that case launched in 1937 by Adolf Hitler’s Minister of Propaganda, Joseph Goebbels. It can happen again. In fact, it HAS happened again. In his closing arguments at my 1994 trial, the prosecutor openly invoked the name Adolf Hitler before my jury.

The Book of Revelation, Chapter 13, speaks of a beast – “a false prophet” – who produces great signs “to deceive the people.” The number of the beast (Revelation 13:18) is “a human number.” It is 666. We’ve seen this beast before in human history, and it didn’t die with Joseph Goebbels and Adolf Hitler.

I hope I’m not the only person to have noticed: the Center for Constitutional Rights – the radical group representing SNAP in its childish, self-serving, misguided, and poorly informed attack on the Church and Pope – is located at 666 Broadway in Manhattan.  (Excerpted from Snap’s Last Gasp)

There is something you might find shocking about the Center for Constitutional Rights that became a willing stooge for SNAP. You’ll find it at the conclusion of my own post on the ICC petition, so I’m giving myself the last word on this. I hope you will read about the agenda of SNAP and the CCR in this scurrilous petition described clearly in “SNAP’s Last Gasp! The Pope’s ‘Crimes Against Humanity.'”

Goebbels Propaganda Against Catholic Priests“The Catholic clergy is collaborating with the enemies of our country in a truly treasonable manner. I could burst with rage when I think that we cannot possibly call the guilty ones to account now. We shall save our vengeance until later. . . A number of Catholic and Protestant ministers have been sentenced to death. They had offended the German armed forces in a most cowardly manner. I proposed to the Führer that the verdicts, together with the opinion of the court, be published.” ~ Joseph Goebbels, Reich Minister of Propaganda

About Fr. Gordon J. MacRae

The late Cardinal Avery Dulles and The Rev. Richard John Neuhaus encouraged Father MacRae to write. Cardinal Dulles wrote in 2005: “Someday your story and that of your fellow sufferers will come to light and will be instrumental in a reform. Your writing, which is clear, eloquent, and spiritually sound will be a monument to your trials.” READ MORE


  1. I have always believed that the so-called priest abuse scandals were more fiction than fact. The patterns of the accusations are similar in nature to the satanic ritual abuse panics of the 1980s, particularly the reliance on “repressed memory,” something that has been largely discredited in the scientific community. The United States is unique in its Predator Panic ™ but it is influencing other counties as well. I am sure there are plenty of real cases (the law of averages suggests it) but when the witch hunt for priest abusers began, there was little oversight into fact-finding.

    Sadly, in the US the mere accusation almost guarantees conviction. Who can prove someone was or wasn’t touched a day ago, much less decades ago? We can’t. With such little oversight, and coupled with the large amounts of settlement offers given to those claiming victimhood status, the chances of false accusations are high.

  2. Liz says:

    We are praying for you all in this heat. I hate it when I see that your forecast is for high temps! Hang in there, Father!

  3. HI Fr Gordon , I will continue too pray for that your long ordeal will soon be over ,IHS.

  4. Dorothy Stein says:

    I hope all your readers will click on the link at the end of this post and as a minimum read the last few paragraphs of that older post called “SNAP’s Last Gasp!” What you have revealed about the Center for Constitutional Rights in Manhattan sent chills down my spine. Are you the only one who has noticed this? Also, for reasons that may be clear to you I found the similarity in tone and content between SNAP’s complaint against The Vatican and Joseph Goebbels’ propaganda campaign against Catholic priests to be utterly stunning.

  5. james P Guzek says:

    Hi Fr. MacRae,

    Peace be with you.

    You are a patient witness of what it is to accept the cross of Christ. God bless you. We are continuing to pray for you.

    Jim Guzek

  6. 69wild17 says:

    Praying for your own wrongful conviction to be overturned very soon, Fr MacRae. You have certainly not been wasting your time while in prison. Your inciteful columns have been teaching us not only our Faith but giving us another view of life we would not ever have known. God is blessing you. Take care Father, I pray for you daily.

  7. Mary Jean Scudieri says:

    Hi Father Gordon!
    What I don’t understand is why SNAP needs to be outraged about something totally made up by them when they could legitimately be outraged over the biggest crime against humanity right now….ABORTION!
    The taking of an unborn child’s life is horrifying to them? It should be to everyone that draws breath because they are truly alive by the grace of God.
    So glad that sense prevailed in the ruling of this case. Now it should do the same for yours.
    Prayers always ongoing! Your friend, Jeannie

  8. CT says:

    I pray for you and all priests (regardless of rank) every day. I desperately want to see you out of prison and justice served. But I can’t help but think that this time has given you a focus and clarity far beyond what you would otherwise have. Given the state of affairs today, I only hope that if we all end up in there with you, that I have a fraction of the grace and clarity that you have. God bless you for keeping us informed and thinking.

  9. Joan Ripley says:

    Thank God! What a relief! Thanks for letting us know, Father Gordon. Hoping for good news soon in your own case and sending up many prayers for God’s blessing upon you and your apostolate there and through TSW.

  10. Liz says:

    Did you see that Fr. Z linked to this today?

    God bless you!

Speak Your Mind